The laughing, alone, is far more damaging and shameful and disgusting and disrespectful than obesity itself. There is such a difference between having criticisms of the way the characters are written and criticizing the actors performance/craft and their leadership in the company. And its funny that you bring up needing constant therapy as a bad thing when a ton of real life people see a therapist on a regular basis. Ichebs torture on Picard was horrible and the eating ganglia in S1, yikes! | December 23, 2020 | In fact, at least on this website, I often see the contrary. And now, with only three years under her belt in the field, From future Starfleets POV, thats 900 years! Id add Kirk to that at several times over the years. I would just be happy if Rhys got more than three lines an episode lol. Before we move on to SuKal this Thursday, there are still some bits to catch up on from the Terra Firma arc of Star Trek: Discovery. Im proud to see that shes proud of herself. The actress also discussed how Killy inspires some fans: Killy is somebody whos very important to a lot of fans, especially my curvy women out there who like to see another full-figured, fat, curvy, chunky woman get to feel powerful and use that size to command authority, said Wiseman. But how the women look?! It just happened. Except that would imply that her being there was the exception rather than the rule. That finale appearance was basically a cameo. Control over ones own body is the most basic freedom we should have. Im glad we are finally seeing it. Do I want to be Barclay or Harry Kim? Sense of morals. How blandly Puritan. Mary Wiseman: Well what is like the same root of Book but like the polar opposite expression of it? When all evidence points to her character not being loved or even liked (the actress is fine; shes been poorly handled by the writers (Michelle Paradise). But respect is always earned and never enforceable. 1:15. He was non-military, the same height as me, and easily weighed 300#. Saru would then recognize the potential in her, give her opportunities to build her self esteem and confidence, and wed get a good arc that doesnt seem forced like it does now. I think the CW has been using something like this for years. PS. So. Everybody loves is an idiom, it should never be taken as a strict statement. Gotta side with Sascha here. Bullied badly as a child and teen so I know what I speak of; Im just glad I grew up pre-Internet, and I sympathize with any nowadays who have to deal with Internet bullying on top of real world bullying. Seasons one through three are available to stream now on CBS All Access. Thats undeniable. Imo, this show tries so overly hard to be socially progressive, its the very thing that makes it a turn-off. No character like her would ever have graduated Starfleet. Can Picard go round the sun once more and rescue Saru from Discovery? The mirror Tilly and the ISS Discovery appear in the "Mirror of Discovery" storyline in Star Trek Online, as part of the game's 9th anniversary in January 2019; she is voiced by Mary Wiseman, who also . :). I think that she is one of the go-to people when there is hard science stuff to crack. The other big issue Ive always had is the graphic nature of violence, this We are TV-MA streaming, so we can do anything attitude I simply hate that. The episode, titled "All Is Possible,". In the season four finale Coming Home, Mary Wiseman returned as Lt. Tilly, now a Starfleet Academy leader working with cadets and Admiral Vance to coordinate the evacuation and defense of Earth on Federation HQ. Just when it looks like the character has finally grown as a person and doing her own thing, comes right back. I think Saru holds out as being the most consistent, and Tilly is close, but not quite. I think Mary is doing a fantastic job as isSonequa, Their characters are fantastic as are all the others. This week's episode raised concerns. Wiseman was appreciative of fans who had her back online: I just want to say that all the people who step in, to back me up like that, your presence is like little angels, like blocking out these little trolls. Every Thursday night I yell Black Alert to let everyone know Im watching Star Trek. Where I live people compete on the merits and are proud of their professional or intellectual achievements not their bad habits, bad health or even born with attributes such as divergent sexual orientation that they had no influence over whatsoever. Its a problem in even some least developed countries now. For people who dont know, it had to do with Voyager leading a fleet of ships going back to the Delta Quadrant a few years after Voyager arrived home. Smart doesnt mean competent. The Enterprise D was the only place we saw a councelor. Understanding? Wiseman had other things to do. Thats not good writing, its oandering fan fiction, Starfleet is not military. I suspect that Prodigy may use some of the elements that Beyer expanded or created for Full Circle without actually developing any of the overall story arc. Jerks. I really liked her in the first season. I agree with you on principle as far at this being fine on a fictional Star Trek show. Right? It explains why each scene is half-redundant and half-contradictory with the others within the same episode. Just like every other character in a show that generally is badly written. She cant control her weight. I see them as similar. Some folks here like this nu trek because it lowered standards to make them feel better about themselves. It doesnt matter either way but with so much Voyager mythology created in those novels, it would be cool to see some of it translated on this show! I know Gene Rodenberry never wanted Starfleet to be portrayed as a military outfit, but this has gone so far in the opposite direction that its being run like a pre-school participation awards ceremony. Mary's fans are curious to know if she is indeed expecting a little one but the rumors are false. Wait I havent watched season 4, nor will I ever after the stupidity that was season 3 But now shes a leader at the academy?! Tillys anxiety got old real fast. Has Tilly body-shaming outside of the Twitter imbeciles been a thing? In CanadaDiscoveryis broadcast on CTV Sci-Fi Channel and streams on Crave. I lovvvve Lilly/Tilly and her curves. Michelle Yeoh, considerably smaller in physical stature, probably weighs around 90# [because she is allll muscle]. Heaven forefend women feel good about themselves! I never thought of Adira as being all that similar, but I see your point. How is she supposed to sound considering nobody knows what people in the 23rd century will talk like? It was EXACTLY what I needed while mourning my own mother. "Hope springs eternal" was the central thesis for Star Trek: Discovery's Season 4 finale . Why do you think being nervous or anxious means that you can not graduate from the academy? Of course my original statement still stands regarding Tilly becoming Sarus Number One. Nah Book is Boba Fett and I want to see the spin-off series THE BOOK OF BOOK :-). So I think we pick up with her after some time has passed since the events of that season, but shes still sort of not really sure what to make of it, and everything that used to be really comfortable isnt sitting as comfortably as it used to if that makes sense. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Please dont ban me!). I KNOW, people say they are great, I was too focused on Star Trek when those were airing, but I might try and give the original show a shot one day. Tilly should have been introduced as female Barclay or a less extreme version of junior lieutenant Picard in Tapestry (the alternate timeline where his career stalled after avoiding getting stabbed in the heart). Mary Wiseman: We dont have that many scenes together but theres a lot of tension between us just as actors and personalities. Shes loved. I would encourage her to do the same. . We love that someone who isnt super fit was cast, especially that its a woman. While Tilly had big dreams in Star Trek: Discovery season 1, she struggled with feelings of inadequacy and was hindered by a social awkwardness that often left her feeling like an outsider. Ive never liked Tilly. The door is open, I suppose, if that show should fail for some reason, but I doubt theyll just throw her back into the same role on the ship like nothing ever happened. So when very capable people feel un-capable, crazy things happen. I do find their quirks annoying at times, but the most important reason I like them is because theyre honest, kind people with a good heart. . I gave this dumpster fire of far left propaganda 4 seasons. Weve seen Captain Killy, so what does Mirror Universe Book look like? DSC has a wonderful cast and a neat diverse set of characters. What do you mean? Finally, actress Rekha Sharma shared this fun behind-the-scenes photo with Doug Jones and David Benjamin Tomlinson, where she lamented Landry being killed off yet again. Given all the trouble the crew got into, Im sure they needed one on the ship. Did Tilly on Discovery gain weight? Of all the issues I have with Star Trek Discovery, Mary Wiseman/Tilly is definitely not among them. Barclays ticks do get really annoying. Where I live people compete on the merits. Obligatory mention of the stupid turbolifts and how dumb they are. In season three Tilly was first officer and then acting captain; how does all of that affect who she is in season four? But was it not made pretty clear that Counselors had become a regular thing on command crews in the TNG era? Try the Daily Mail for 5 minutes. There is a great scene back in S1 when Tilly and Burnham are doing cardio training and post workout are eating their protien, carbs and fat nutrition, something that the body requires after a hard cardio workout. So I think Tilly definitely goes to employ those skills. Ive learned a lot of bad spelling comes from dictating into your smartphone. The writers may love the character, but they also appreciate that the actor is a real person who might want variety in their career. )Granted, I think the special effects, space battles, bizarre technology and explosions are the proverbial tail wagging the dog, but thats always been the case, and is increasingly expected in these post-Star Wars, high tech decades. Please back up your statement. I do not endorse body-shaming in any way, as I was bullied as a kid years ago. Im sorry but what youve described about Tilly is like something out of a Nickelodeon teen high school drama. To even suggest that is stupidity writ large. She is most recognized for her roles in the science fiction drama series Star Trek: Discovery on Paramount+, where she first played Cadet, then Ensign, and finally . I know a thing or two about haters-pay no mind. Star Trek: Discovery Season 5 May Be Coming Soon, According To Wilson Cruz [UPDATED], Podcast: All Access Scans For All The Latest Star Trek Universe News, Star Trek Lower Decks Nominated For Annie Award; Discovery For NAACP And GLAAD Awards, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/97519/all-access-picard-episode-303-seventeen-seconds-review-discovery-ending-future-of-star-trek-discussion.mp3, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/97356/shuttle-pod-113-star-trek-picard-season-3-chat-on-the-next-generation-disengage.mp3, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/97216/all-access-review-of-star-trek-picard-episode-302-disengage.mp3, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/96813/all-access-review-of-star-trek-picard-episode-301-the-next-generation.mp3, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/96521/all-access-suplimental-john-billingsley-interview.mp3. It's mostly the super-hero genre where you see this. If that happens, I'm betting she'll be a part of it. Youre perfect as you are. [1] Early life [ edit] Wiseman is the youngest daughter of Dorothy and Kevin Wiseman and has three older brothers. Star Trek is supposed to be socially progressive but this show went too far. Wasnt it Saru who made Tilly the First Officer? My personal opinion is, if you see ribs in their low decolletage, they are probably not so healthy. Theyve written Tilly as just the straight oh theres Tilly for the jokes. It always cracks me up when people say that they hate Tilly. All are Trek! I have nothing against Mary Wiseman. Most of what she did was convey the amazingly obvious like offering such useful insights such as, Hes concealing something but I dont know what. And her abilities were never fully defined. Thats a crumpet I want to butter. [laughter], David Ajala as Book and Sonequa Martin-Green as Michael in episode 401 Kobayashi Maru. Between Marys comments about how Tilly internalizes her experiences as acting First Officer and Captain and the fact that we see Gen Rhys in the big chair in one of the early production stills, does anyone think that Discovery might get Treks first regular series Asian First Officer? I actually had an entire epic story mapped out that I was seriously considering turning into a series of novels. She hopped over those 900 years. But then again Im not a troll. Hey writers room go back to TNG and see how a child became an honourary bridge officer on the Enterprise D. (something equally puzzling to say the least) Picard did it because the Traveller who could traverse space time and see the future and past told Picard it was extremely important to encourage the boy. Theres a difference between celebrating obesity and accepting individual human beings, treating them as human beings, and not targeting them specifically for emotional harassment. Where are they!? Not Mary Wisemans fault; the writers fault. What accent? 42 comments so far. Respectfully, to anyone somehow offended by that. And I know Chakotay was also Captain on Voyager in those books as well. Star Trek: Discovery's Mary Wiseman and Blu del Barrio reflect on their character's journeys and the possibilities ahead. Everybody loves Tilly. Except the writers of course. But Im just happy we are talking about Voyager again, especially since this show is basically a spin off of it! TrekMovie.com is not endorsed, sponsored or affiliated with CBS Studios Inc., Paramount Pictures Corp. or the Star Trek franchise. Barclay was funny and silly but relatable due to his social anxiety. He was a cool character and one of the best things about season 3. That said, the stolid approach to characterization has its benefits as well when an emotional outburst happens it can be devastating (see: Picards breakdowns in the likes of Family, Chain of Command, First Contact), but it also allows for subtler moments to have outsized impacts (Odo asking Garak to breakfast, Seven revealing her favorite color, Picards 1/4 smiles when no one is looking, Spocks eyebrow etc), which is also quite true to life. The visual reboot premise was overstretched. Well, the entire point is she absolutely looks the way I expect her to. Even though she's still in the final season of Starfleet Aacademy studies She was assigned to the USS Discovery to get some practical experience. I suppose thats why some places are rising and others are very visibly in decline. She makes it all look so easy. So sayeth Scotty, the contrarian. Those b@stards, however, totally killed Landry )Cuddles with @actordougjones and @davbentom These men are nothing short of hereoic in prosthetics all day e'reday. They have solved some of these issues the easy way by talking themselves out of it (Klingon hair, holograms, Ariam being no android at all), now that we are in the future none of it really matters anymore. They made an insensitive statement about her body and called her a promoter of an unhealthy lifestyle. It is not yet known what role, if any, Wisemans Tilly would have in the upcoming season, with possibilities ranging from guest or recurring character to becoming a series regular again. Maybe Saru wont be on the ship as much but Im guessing they are going the same direction. The moment they decided to incorporate a new character with basically the same characteristics (a young, socially awkward, but very smart ensign) they ruined Tilly. But its the elephant we have in the room, these days. It really doesnt fit in the century they are in. I am a therapist in real life, and even *I* think it was crazy that they had a therapist on the bridge. BTW, I know this is waaaaaay off topic, but since you are the literary Trek lover on this site and keep up with a lot of the books, do you think Prodigy is going to use some of Kirsten Beyers Full Circle Voyager story lines? And a. Lwaxana Troi, Tilly is frankly nowhere near as annoying as those other characters. Star Trek: Discovery threw a shocker into its latest episode as Lieutenant Sylvia Tilly decided to leave the Discovery crew. And thats a healthy outlook. Episodes will be. I wonder if there is any news that she might be pregnant. Take me to the stars and tell me a story. I hope were able to explore it because theres potential for great levity, but then also really important conversations to be had because when you care about someone you dont want to see them go through pain, and I can see completely how Tilly will be very protective of Michael Burnham. That promise was. The writing for him is trying in season 1, but from Samaritan Snare onwards I actually think hes kinda endearing and has decent utility. Shes one of the shows most divisive characters. Star Trek: Discovery Season 5 May Be Coming Soon, According To Wilson Cruz [UPDATED], Podcast: All Access Scans For All The Latest Star Trek Universe News, Star Trek Lower Decks Nominated For Annie Award; Discovery For NAACP And GLAAD Awards, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/97519/all-access-picard-episode-303-seventeen-seconds-review-discovery-ending-future-of-star-trek-discussion.mp3, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/97356/shuttle-pod-113-star-trek-picard-season-3-chat-on-the-next-generation-disengage.mp3, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/97216/all-access-review-of-star-trek-picard-episode-302-disengage.mp3, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/96813/all-access-review-of-star-trek-picard-episode-301-the-next-generation.mp3, http://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/trekmovie.com/podcast-player/96521/all-access-suplimental-john-billingsley-interview.mp3. Andrew: Great, perceptive, thoughtful post! It was so fun. Thematic darkness is fine but graphic visuals arent. I like me. When Mary Wiseman's Lt. Sylvia Tilly left the USS Discovery for a job at the new Starfleet Academy in the fourth episode of season four, it was promised she would be back. By: TrekMovie.com Staff She is a real girl. Thats the thing about DSC. With his skill and abilities, we will see how he may use them in a way that may affect his relationship with Michael Burnham. Then maybe I would actually remember his name! Not liking a character doesnt make a person a troll, so Im not even sure what that nonsensical comment was supposed to mean. You know what, fvck you, Vulcan Soul. The burden is now on SNWThat show can either make or break it with regards to these issues. Overweight is a risk of becoming obese. Heck I think it was more unrealistic when some chick was upset he wasn't ready for sex. For someone who is supposed to care about others, shes been remarkably stuck in her own emotions. She hasnt mentored anyone except in one episode. Ill never forget when I, a woman of 160# at 58, healthy, deemed fit by military and bodyfat percentage indexes, approached the Credit Union one day, when the guy at the ATM finished his transaction, turned, saw me, and yelled Hey, fatass!. However, Tilly's rise to Lieutenant in Thursday's episode of Star Trek: Discovery did not invoke feelings of joy. Fitness may be in the eye of the beholder, as hes commented himself that contempories his age have to hit the head just a bit more often. I found him quite annoying, myself. I think criticism of the actors is wrong as well, its not about the actors its what they have been told deliver. I let go of my preconceptions about what star trek is. Neither she nor anyone else with common sense is celebrating obesity. I feel bad saying this but Ive never a read a Star Trek novel in my life lol. Good for Mary! The problem is, very deep into his 80s, and theres still chatter about him playing the action hero. For me, DS9 was the best Star Trek Show for character development. Just IMHO, because to each his (or her, or their) own! The 60s/70s are gone.